A few months ago, an industrial service company in Chicago came to us almost $300,000 in the hole on a sales hire that did not work. Wrong rep, wrong territory, lost revenue, lost time. The owner had been trying to fix it himself, dozens of interviews deep, and was ready to give up.
It did not take long to diagnose the problem. Two problems, actually.
First, he was relying entirely on inbound applicants. You can hire that way. It is just unlikely to land you the person you actually want, because the salespeople you actually want are not applying. They are busy hitting quota somewhere else.
Second, he was not prepared to sell his company. His discovery process was built to weed candidates out, full stop. There was no pitch, no story, no reason for an A-player to choose him.
That second one is the one most hiring managers miss.
Interviewing a salesperson is a sales conversation. In every sales conversation, both sides are deciding. If you don't recognize that, you'll lose every A-player you talk to. Marshall Scabet, Founder and CEO, Precision Sales Recruiting
If you do not recognize that dynamic, you will lose every A-player you talk to and end up settling for the candidate who needed the job more than you needed them. That is exactly how mis-hires happen in manufacturing sales, where long sales cycles can hide weak performance for six months or more.
How to Spot a Top Sales Candidate in an Interview
A-players give themselves away if you know what to watch for. Here are five tells.
A-players establish position in the first few minutes. They do it by asking great discovery questions. Are you backfilling the role? Why did the last hire not work out? What is your differentiator? Who would I report to? Who is the coach in this organization?
In short: what problem do you have, and why? They want to make sure they are not wasting their time or yours. If it is not a fit, they will walk away.
Most interviewers cannot see this happening. A-players do not deliver perfectly canned answers to perfectly canned questions. That is what most interviewers think they should be looking for. It is not.
A real sales professional listens for the problem and demonstrates how they would solve it. If they cannot do that in an interview, they cannot do it in front of your customer either.
They know who they are, what they are capable of, and they are not afraid to lose this deal. The interview is a deal to them. An untrained interviewer is going to get offended by this. The A-player does not need you. They have options. Their LinkedIn inbox is full.
Ask an A-player to "tell you their greatest weakness" and they are already searching for the exit. They are too professional to end the call abruptly. But you can be certain they are done. They will finish politely and never return your follow-up.
Nothing annoys a top sales candidate more than talking to an interviewer who has never sold and never carried a quota. Salespeople respect other salespeople. They want to know the person evaluating them understands the work.
The candidate who agrees with everything you say is the same candidate who will fold the first time a customer pushes back on price.
What to Do About It
If you want to actually hire A-players, four things matter more than anything else.
Put a Salesperson in the Interview
Whoever evaluates the candidate should have carried a quota. Salespeople evaluate sales skills faster and more accurately than anyone else. A great hiring manager paired with HR is a strong combination. HR alone is not.
Build a Process
Many founders believe they can sell. The unpopular truth is that many cannot. Their name gets the meeting, their relationships close the deal, and they have no idea how they actually do it. If you cannot describe your sales process in five steps, you do not have one. And if you do not have one, you cannot hire against it. Our 4-phase recruiting process was built for exactly this reason.
Build a Scorecard
Score every candidate. Be intentional about the questions. Score consistently across the panel. This is the difference between a hiring decision based on data and one based on who interviewed last on a Friday afternoon. See how we structure candidate evaluation with a sales candidate scorecard.
Role Play
The highest-signal tool in a sales interview. If a candidate cannot run a discovery call against you in a controlled exercise, they cannot run one against your customer either. We use calibrated role plays as one of three layers inside our proprietary evaluation framework, and the difference between candidates who interview well and candidates who can actually sell becomes obvious within ten minutes.
The owner stopped guessing. We ran the search, brought him three vetted candidates, and he hired the second one. He is still there, hitting his number.
A bad sales hire is not just a fee. It is six to eighteen months of lost execution, a stalled territory, and a customer base that quietly moved to a competitor. It is worth getting right the first time.
If you are hiring sales talent in Chicago or anywhere else in industrial B2B, let's talk. We will show you how we would run your search before you commit to anything.
Hiring Sales Talent and Tired of Guessing?
Precision Sales Recruiting works exclusively in manufacturing and industrial B2B sales. We source passive candidates, run structured evaluations, and deliver vetted shortlists in five business days. Average placement time of 18 days, backed by a 12-month replacement guarantee.
Book a Client Strategy CallShare this post: